4 Ways to Turn Reliability into a Promotion 📈

When Being Brilliant at Your Job Becomes Your Biggest Career Obstacle

The fluorescent lights hummed overhead as I sat in yet another "career development" meeting with my manager at Microsoft. Same script, different quarter.

"Harvey, you're absolutely invaluable to this team. Honestly, I don't know what we'd do without you."

Brilliant, I thought. Here comes the 'but.'

"But the timing just isn't right for a promotion. We need you exactly where you are. You're too valuable to move."

Six words that would haunt my next 18 months: "You're too valuable where you are."

Sound familiar? If you've been nodding along thinking "That's exactly what happened to me," then congratulations - you've stumbled into what I now call the Reliability Trap. It's career quicksand disguised as a compliment, and it's quietly killing more careers than a poor LinkedIn headshot.

Welcome to the Dependability Paradox

After years of coaching professionals across Amazon, Microsoft, Salesforce, and beyond, I've spotted a pattern more predictable than a British summer: the most dependable professionals wait twice as long for promotion.

It's the ultimate workplace irony. You deliver flawlessly, become the go-to person for everything that matters, and suddenly moving you feels "too risky" to leadership. Meanwhile, that colleague who's about as reliable as a chocolate teapot somehow leaps ahead of you.

The brutal truth? No one promotes their best firefighter during the fire.

But here's what makes this particularly maddening: your stellar reputation—the very thing you've worked so hard to build—becomes the prison bars holding you back. You've become so bloody good at your current role that everyone's terrified to let you evolve beyond it.

The Four Invisible Chains

Let me paint you a picture of how this trap works:

Chain 1: You deliver flawlessly → Your manager grows to rely on your execution

Chain 2: Moving you feels "too risky" → Less reliable peers leap ahead

Chain 3: You become resentful → Your performance actually starts to slip

Chain 4: Now you're neither promoted nor performing → It's a vicious cycle that turns your greatest strength into your biggest liability.

I've watched brilliant professionals waste years in this pattern, thinking that if they just work a bit harder, deliver a bit more consistently, someone will finally notice their potential.

Spoiler alert: they won't. They'll just pile on more work because you're "so reliable."

The Great Escape: Four Strategic Shifts

The good news? This trap can be dismantled. But it requires a fundamental shift in how you operate - and more importantly, how others perceive your value.

Shift 1: Strategic Value Creation

❌ Stop being the task master ✅ Start being the opportunity finder

Instead of saying: "I've completed all the quarterly reports on time." Start saying: "I've identified a £2.1M opportunity in X that we're currently missing."

This isn't about working harder; it's about speaking in outcomes, not checklists. Your manager doesn't get promoted for having someone who ticks boxes brilliantly—they get promoted for having someone who identifies revenue opportunities.

Shift 2: Replacement Strategy

❌ Don't hoard the know-how ✅ Build bench strength

Here's the counterintuitive bit: you need to actively work yourself out of your current role. Delegate 30% of your workload. Train others to do what you do. Document your processes.

Why? Because leaders promote those who scale, not those who hoard. If you're the only person who can do your job, you'll be doing it forever.

Shift 3: Decision Altitude

❌ Don't just "do" ✅ Think and speak at the next level

Start every presentation with: "The strategic implication of this is..." End every project update with: "Looking ahead, this positions us to..."

You need to operate like your future title, not your current one. If you want to be a Director, start thinking like a Director. If you want to be a VP, start speaking like a VP.

Shift 4: Visibility Architecture

❌ Don't wait to be discovered ✅ Engineer strategic exposure

"I'd like to present this at the leadership meeting" should become your new favourite phrase. Be in the rooms where decisions happen, not just where work gets done.

This isn't about office politics - it's about strategic positioning. You can't get promoted to roles you're invisible for.

Why This Works (And Why It Feels Uncomfortable)

The reason most high performers struggle with this approach is that it feels like you're abandoning what made you successful in the first place. Your reliability, your attention to detail, your ability to deliver - these aren't weaknesses. They're superpowers.

But superpowers without strategy just make you really good at your current level.

The professionals I've coached who successfully escape this trap don't become less reliable - they become strategically reliable. They channel their dependability into building systems, developing others, and creating value at a higher altitude.

One client went from "too essential to promote" to Senior Director in just 18 months using exactly this framework. Another moved from being the "spreadsheet guru" to VP of Operations by shifting how she positioned her analytical skills.

The pattern is always the same: reliability keeps you stuck, strategy gets you seen.

The Bottom Line

If you've ever felt like your dependability has become your biggest liability, you're not paranoid - you're perceptive. The Reliability Trap is real, and it's keeping brilliant professionals stuck at levels far below their potential.

But here's the thing: the very skills that got you trapped are the same skills that will get you out. You just need to redirect them.

Stop being the person who makes everyone else's job easier. Start being the person who makes everyone else's job possible.

Your Action Plan for This Week:

1. Audit your current role: What percentage of your time is spent on tasks vs. strategy? Aim to flip this ratio over the next quarter.

2. Document one major process: Write down exactly how you do something critical. This is your first step towards building bench strength.

3. Identify one strategic opportunity: Look beyond your current responsibilities. What's not being done that should be?

4. Book a meeting: Find one leadership meeting, strategy session, or cross-functional project you can contribute to. Get yourself in the room.

5. Change your language: For the next week, replace "I completed X" with "I delivered X, which enables us to Y."

Remember: this isn't about working harder. It's about reframing how others perceive your value. Your reliability is an asset - just make sure it's an asset that scales.

Keep on rockin'!

Harvey.

Hey 👋

Thousands of readers like you are loving Backstage Pass - my award-winning, #1 bestselling book.

It’s not just a story. It’s a career-changing experience wrapped in rock and roll.

“Lee’s storytelling doesn’t just entertain; it lights a fire under you.” – 5★ Goodreads

Start your journey 👉 harvey-lee.com/book

PS. If you've read it, you’ve earned the right to shape its future. Your Amazon review helps more readers discover it. 🙏